A deadly confrontation between U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents and a civilian in Minneapolis has sparked intense controversy, protests, and conflicting narratives from federal and local officials. On January 7, 2026, an ICE agent fatally shot 37-year-old Renee Nicole Good during an immigration enforcement operation in south Minneapolis. Videos of the incident have gone viral, fueling debates over whether the shooting was justified self-defense or an excessive use of force.
What Happened: A Step-by-Step Breakdown
The incident unfolded around 9:40 a.m. on Portland Avenue near 34th Street, in the diverse Central neighborhood close to Powderhorn Park and less than a mile from the site of George Floyd’s 2020 death.
- A maroon Honda Pilot SUV, driven by Good, was stopped in the street, partially blocking the path of ICE vehicles during a targeted enforcement operation.
- Masked ICE agents approached the vehicle. One attempted to open the driver’s door and reached inside the open window, while another positioned himself near the front.
- Good reversed slightly, then shifted into drive and began maneuvering to leave the area, turning away from the agents.
- An agent near the front fired three shots through the driver’s side window.
- The SUV accelerated, crashing into parked cars and a light pole. Good was found slumped over and later pronounced dead at a hospital.
Bystander videos, verified by outlets like The New York Times, show several feet of separation between the vehicle and the shooting agent, with no agents appearing struck. However, some angles shared by conservative sources suggest the vehicle may have clipped or approached an agent closely.
View this post on Instagram
Conflicting Narratives: Federal vs. Local Accounts
The shooting has highlighted sharp divisions:
- Federal Perspective (DHS/ICE): Spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin described Good as part of “rioters” who “weaponized her vehicle” in an attempt to run over officers—an “act of domestic terrorism.” DHS Secretary Kristi Noem and President Trump echoed this, calling the agent’s actions self-defense to protect lives. They framed the operation as necessary to address illegal immigration and fraud.
- Local and State Perspective: Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey called the self-defense claim “bullshit” and “garbage” after viewing video, demanding ICE “get the f*ck out of Minneapolis” for causing “chaos.” Governor Tim Walz labeled the incident “totally predictable” and “totally avoidable,” criticizing the Trump administration’s “dangerous” operations. Police Chief Brian O’Hara stated there was no indication Good was a target of enforcement and she appeared to be a “legal observer” or community protector. Officials emphasized she was a U.S. citizen not involved in any targeted activity.
The FBI and Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension are investigating, with local prosecutors pushing for transparency and potential state charges if the force is deemed unreasonable.
View this post on Instagram